Forest, Range & Recreation Resource Analysis Table of Contents

5.3 Condition of the Recreation Resource

This section outlines how recreational and non-recreational uses can affect the recreation resource, describes mechanisms for protecting important recreation values and provides information on the condition of the recreation resource in provincial forests.

5.3.1 Uses Affecting the Recreation Resource

This section illustrates how both recreational and non-recreational resource use can affect the condition of the recreation resource.[76]

Recreation Uses

Recreation activities can change recreation opportunity settings, sometimes in unplanned or undesirable ways. For example, primitive settings can be changed to semiprimitive by the construction of new recreation facilities or by increased levels of use. Semiprimitive non-motorized settings can be changed to semiprimitive motorized with motorized backcountry recreation use.

Increased use or changes in the type of use or behavior of users, can damage recreation facilities (e.g., sites and trails) through trampling, removal or scarring of vegetation and soil compaction. Similarly, overuse can degrade a recreation setting or experience, such as through crowding.

Recreationists may damage recreation resources through actions such as removing cultural heritage features or natural features such as fossils or vegetation or by harassing wildlife. Illegal or inappropriate behavior — such as vandalism, rowdyism, poaching and littering — can damage recreation features (including wildlife) and facilities and destroy the outdoor recreation experience for others.

Non-Recreation Uses

Non-recreation resource uses such as logging and mining can also affect the condition of the recreation resource. Two major impacts are on visual landscapes and on recreation opportunity settings.

Resource use activities can change the character of viewscapes. Studies have confirmed that the public prefers to view unaltered natural landscapes.[77] Resource development activities can significantly alter natural landscapes in visually sensitive areas if appropriate visual quality objectives are not established and corresponding visual landscape design techniques are not followed.

The most pronounced effects of resource use activities on recreation opportunity settings are from construction of access roads. New roads expand roaded recreation opportunities and make many previously remote backcountry areas and wild rivers more accessible to more people. At the same time, increased road access reduces roadless areas and opportunities for remote or primitive backcountry recreation opportunities. In other words, increased access can increase the amount of recreation use, but it can also change and sometimes diminish the quality of the recreation experience.

Resource use activities can also directly affect recreation features. Some recreation features, such as caves associated with karst landforms, may be particularly sensitive to disturbance.

5.3.2 Protection Measures

The character of the recreation resource will change with recreational and non-recreational use. Sometimes, the nature of this change is clearly damaging (e.g., damage to features and facilities) and sometimes it is less clear (e.g., changes to recreation opportunity settings). A key challenge is to determine when change is appropriate and when it is not.

Protection measures are ways to safeguard important recreation resources from unacceptable change or damage. Protection measures include:

Protected Areas and Related Designations

Protected areas are defined in the Protected Areas Strategy (PAS) as areas set aside for the protection of cultural heritage values, conservation and recreation, where resource extraction (e.g., logging, mining, hydro dam construction, oil and gas development) is not allowed.78 PAS targets 12% of B.C. to be in protected areas by the year 2000. Protected area designations include national and provincial parks and ecological reserves. Other related designations include recreation areas and wilderness areas, where logging is prohibited, but mining may be allowed.

In 1984, approximately 5 million hectares (about 5% of B.C.) were in various protected areas and related designations in B.C. In the last 10 years, there has been a 50% increase in area protected, with a total of about 8.2 million hectares (or 8.6% of B.C.) as of December 31, 1994. Figure 5.8 summarizes the protected areas situation for each forest region.

There have been two distinct periods of growth in protected areas in the last 10 years. Between 1986 and 1989, 15 new large areas (greater than 10 000 ha) totalling 880 000 hectares were established. These designations primarily stemmed from government response to the recommendations of the Wilderness Advisory Committee.[79] They included 11 recreation areas, three wilderness areas and one national park reserve. Nine new large protected areas and many smaller protected areas (totalling 1.8 million ha) were established between 1990 and 1994. One area alone, the Tatshenshini-Alsek, is about 1 million ha. These new protected areas were announced under the Protected Areas Strategy.

In 1987, the Forest Act was amended to recognize wilderness as a resource in provincial forests and to enable government to designate wilderness areas. Wilderness areas are established to maintain natural ecosystems and to provide wilderness backcountry recreation opportunities. There are now four wilderness areas totalling 130 000 ha: Height-of-the-Rockies, Upper Stein, Lower Stein and Swan Lake. By law, logging is prohibited in designated wilderness areas, but mining activities are not.

Map Notations, Reserves and Study Areas

Important recreation resources can be given a level of protection (or interim protection) through establishment of map notations, reserves, and study areas. Map notations can be established for a variety of purposes, including recreation. Recreation reserves include reserves for the use, recreation and enjoyment of the public (UREPs). There are about 4000 areas with map notations or reserves for recreation values where any proposed use must be reviewed by recreation staff to minimize conflict with recreation values.

Map notations have also been established for Cabinet-approved study areas under the Protected Areas Strategy. Study areas are established for the interim protection of natural, cultural heritage and recreation resources while the areas are being reviewed to determine if they should become protected areas. There are over 100 large study areas (greater than 1000 hectares) and about 70 small study areas under interim protection.[80]

Figure 5.9 summarizes map notations, reserves, recreation interest areas and study areas by forest region. Recreation interest areas are areas where map notations are being actively considered. Estimates for reserves, notations and interest areas are based on preliminary data in the Forest Tenure Administration System (FTAS) and likely underestimate the actual area. Nevertheless, based on this preliminary assessment, about 11 million hectares (about 11% of B.C.) occur in these various categories. Most of these areas are in map notations established for study areas. Virtually all of these areas, except UREP reserves, have been established during the last 10 years.

Recreation Sites, Recreation Trails, Heritage Trails and Interpretive Forest Sites

The Forest Act provides for the formal establishment of recreation sites and trails. Many of the recreation sites and trails are under map notation or reserve, but many are not. The ministry developed and actively manages about 1360 Forest Service recreation sites and 541 managed trails stretching over 5000 kilometres. Recreation sites range from a few hectares to over 5000 hectares in size. Recreation trails range from a few kilometres to several hundred kilometres in length. In addition, about 1800 inactive (unmanaged) recreation sites and about 150 inactive trails are under map notation or reserve.

Under the Heritage Conservation Act, seven heritage trails totalling about 500 kilometres in length have been designated in provincial forests as of 1994. The length of heritage trails also varies from a few kilometres to the 350-kilometre Alexander Mackenzie Heritage Trail. There are an additional 11 heritage trails under study for possible designation. Heritage trails are cooperatively managed by the Ministry of Forests and the Ministry of Small Business, Tourism and Culture.

In 1992, the Forest Act was amended to formally recognize interpretive forest sites — their purpose is to foster dialogue with the public and increase understanding about B.C.’s forests and how they are managed. The ministry had 59 interpretive forest sites in 1988 and 97 sites in 1993. Most of these sites have been established during the last 10 years.

Forest Practices Code

The Forest Practices Code (FPC) was enacted in 1994 to ensure important forest resources, including the recreation resource, are protected by law. The code provides for the formal establishment of resource management zones, landscape units and sensitive areas where resource management objectives must be identified. It also provides more stringent and enforceable regulations for resource protection and enables supporting standards and field guides to be developed.

Establishing objectives through the FPC is critical to the provision of outdoor recreation opportunities and the protection of recreation resources. For example, visual quality objectives (VQOs) need to be established to protect scenic landscapes and recreation opportunity spectrum (ROS) objectives need to be established to protect wilderness and backcountry recreation opportunities.

Land Use and Operational Planning

In the last 10 years, many land use planning processes have identified areas with important resource values, including recreation. In 1991, for example, Ministry of Forests recreation staff assisted 476 strategic and operational planning projects. Many of the areas with recreation values identified through these processes may be more formally established under the Code.

Land use planning processes frequently address recreation and tourism resource values collectively in socioeconomic and resource analyses. For these reasons, Section 5.4 on recreation use and Section 7.3 on the economic value of recreation also address the recreation/tourism overlap.

In the Prince Rupert Forest Region, 25 areas totalling over 3 million hectares (about 11% of the region) have been identified through various land use planning processes as warranting special management for recreation (including visual resources and wilderness). For example, recreation values are given special consideration in a Cabinet-approved management plan for the Lower Stikine.[81] Examples in other regions include local resource use plans that recognize important scenic values in the Robson Valley in the Prince George Forest Region and along the Barkerville corridor in the Cariboo Forest Region.

Recreation Management Planning

Recreation planning refers to operational planning focused on the protection and management of important recreation resources. Examples include wilderness management plans for the Height-of-the-Rockies Wilderness Area,[82] management plans for the Hudson’s Bay Company and Alexander MacKenzie heritage trails,[83] and cave management plans.

In 1991, there were 108 site and trail development plans, which frequently precede development work.

Referrals

The referral of various plans and proposed management actions to recreation staff provide another opportunity for important recreation resource values to be considered before operational decisions are made. For the three-year period 1989-1991, recreation staff received 16 828 referrals and reviewed 15 176 (about 90%) of them.

Tenures and Management Agreements

B.C. Environment and B.C. Lands tenure certain commercial recreation activities such as guide-outfitting and heli-skiing. B.C. Lands is developing a comprehensive commercial backcountry recreation policy. Licensing provides an opportunity to specify how the recreation resource is to be protected.

Although the Ministry of Forests does not tenure recreation use in provincial forests, it has signed management agreements with organizations to provide opportunities for cooperative management and protection of the recreation resource. For example, several winter trails for cross-country skiing are under management agreements.


Return to top Return Forward